Homes for Sale in Old Cutler Bay

Discover all Old Cutler Bay homes for sale and real estate listings below. Register for a free account so you can receive email alerts whenever a new home in Old Cutler Bay (that matches your criteria) is listed in Coral Gables's largest MLS.

Old Cutler Bay Real Estate May 29, 2024
Avg. DOM
Avg. $ / Sq.Ft.
Med. List Price
5 Properties

The Old Cutler Bay gated entrance

Old Cutler Bay Information

Located at the southern edge of Coral Gables, on 150 acres of lush tropical vegetation, Old Cutler Bay is a very secluded gated community that offers residents a tranquil escape from the hustle and bustle of city life. Architecturally designed mansions and estate homes nestled along the waterfront, offering stunning views of Biscayne Bay, and residents enjoy a laid-back lifestyle that centers around boating, swimming, and relaxing with neighbors. 

Quiet, tree-lined streets wind through Old Cutler, providing a safe environment for local kids to ride their bikes. Matheson Hammock Park and R Hardy Matheson County Preserve lie adjacent to Old Cutler Bay, adding to the sense of this neighborhood as a secluded oasis, as well as providing locals with numerous outdoor activities. Although Downtown Miami, Brickell, and the Miami Design District are all just minutes away, this picturesque neighborhood feels far removed from an urban environment.

Old Cutler has Gables Estates and Cocoplum neighborhoods to the north. The waterfront properties of the community are also near the neighborhoods of Hammocks and Hammock Oaks.

Old Cutler is also close to some of Miami’s parks like Pinecrest Gardens and Matheson Hammock Park. Deering Bay Marina at the nearby Deering Bay is only a few minutes away from the neighborhood. Deering Estate and Deering Bay Yacht Club are also near the neighborhood.

Some of the most updated and upscale shopping centers in Miami like Miracle Mile, The Falls and Dadeland Mall are all within minutes away from the neighborhood.

Old Cutler Bay is located in Coral Gables, FL within Miami Dade County. The zip code for the community is 33156.

Homes within Old Cutler Bay were built from 1964 to 2020. A typical residence in the community is a two-story home that features 5 bedrooms and 4 bathrooms.

In terms of interior living space, homes in Old Cutler Bay range between 2689 and 10308 square feet, and the average total lot size is between 0.5 to 0.75 acres.

Below are the Old Cutler Bay public school districts:

  • Elementary: Sunset
  • Junior High: Ponce De Leon
  • High: Coral Gables

Old Cutler Bay Realtors®

For more information about Old Cutler Bay homes or to schedule a private showing, contact our expert Old Cutler Bay real estate agents today. This page is directly updated directly from the largest MLS in Miami Dade County so feel free to bookmark this page to keep up to date on the latest listings.

If you’re thinking of buying a home, contact our Old Cutler Bay real estate agents who are the LOCAL experts who can assist you with your search and answer all of your neighborhood questions.

If you’re thinking of selling your home in Old Cutler Bay or in the Coral Gables area, our listing agents can provide information on recently sold nearby properties and up-to-date information about the real estate market.