14 Best Island Communities In Miami
Surrounding the vibrant mainland of Miami are a myriad of island communities that offer some of the most beautiful and exclusive neighborhoods in all of South Florida. Here is a roundup of the best island communities Miami has to offer:
1. Star Island
Star Island is the pinnacle of exclusivity and prestige. Located west of South Beach in the emerald waters of Biscayne Bay, Star Island offers one of the most enviable locations in all of South Florida. As an extremely private locale, Star Island has just over thirty opulent waterfront mansions and villas and includes a single guarded access point off the MacArthur Causeway.
These exquisite estates sit on large waterfront lots of over an acre, and many estates have private docks for luxury yachts and speedboats with unencumbered direct access into Biscayne Bay. Each residence is an architectural masterpiece with the utmost refinement and style, flawlessly representing Meditteranean, Spanish, modern, and European-inspired designs.
Lavish entrances, meticulously landscaped outdoor living areas, expansive pools, and posh guest houses are all standard amenities of these extravagant estates. Breathtaking 360-degree views of Biscayne Bay and the downtown Miami skyline can be enjoyed from these mansions set in a tropical paradise.
Star Island provides residents with absolute privacy, anonymity, and distinction but is also close to some of the finest restaurants, clubs, and shopping that South Beach is famous for. For these reasons, some of the most recognized celebrities, athletes, entertainers, and business elite call Star Island their home.
2. Indian Creek Island
Aptly known as the “Billionaire Bunker,” Indian Creek Island is considered the most secure and exclusive island in Florida and possibly the world. This breathtaking island spans 300 acres and features forty regal waterfront estates with stunning views of sparkling Biscayne Bay. The island has long been an enclave for the extremely wealthy and privileged, including star athletes, entertainers, politicians, CEOs, and top celebrities.
The island provides the highest level of security to protect residents with a thirteen-person police force, strict guarded access to the island, and 24/7 patrol of the waters surrounding the island. Only one access point is available onto the island’s one street that runs the island's length. The world-renowned Indian Creek Country Club has occupied the interior of the island since the 1930s. The 18-hole course and the surrounding club grounds are perfectly manicured with an impressive Spanish-style clubhouse. The members-only club is highly exclusive, with a very limited and prestigious member roster.
Homes on the island sit all along the perimeter, taking full advantage of the gorgeous bay views. The island’s residences are an impressive mix of Meditteranean, contemporary, eco-friendly, and European style mansions, all set on multi-acre lots. Indian Creek Island’s homes are lavish and opulent, exuding the highest sense of class and seclusion.
3. Hibiscus Island
Hibiscus Island is one of the many artificial islands created in the 1920s during the Florida land boom. Since its creation, the island has attracted the world’s wealthy and elite in search of a tropical winter haven. Privacy is paramount on the island, with a single point of access off the MacArthur Causeway, leading into the guard-gated entrance.
The peaceful neighborhood is lined with swaying palm trees and beautiful tropical flora and fauna. The close-knit community is passionate about the island’s preservation and privacy; many residents are a part of the local association to further these goals. A quaint and inviting park is shared between Hibiscus Island and its sister island, Palm Island. It offers amenities that include a basketball court, tennis courts, racquetball courts, picnic areas, and a children’s playground.
A mix of gorgeous waterfront and dry lot mansions and villas line the island with a variety of elevations, including modern, Mediterranean, Spanish, and European-style. Views of enchanting Biscayne Bay, the downtown Miami skyline, and luxury cruise ships coming into the Port of Miami can be seen from the homes’ attractive balconies and rooftop lounge areas. Waterfront homes offer direct access into the bay with deep enough waters for private boat dockage.
4. Palm Island
Palm Island has long been a tropical retreat for the rich and famous with its exclusive location and luxurious waterfront properties. The island offers residents privacy and peace of mind with only one access point via the MacArthur Causeway and a secure guarded entry gate. An exquisite old-world Spanish-style tiered fountain and palm trees can be seen upon entering the island.
An inviting park with facilities for tennis, basketball, racquetball, and a children’s playground are all available for residents’ enjoyment. Exquisite waterfront and dry lot homes dot the 82-acre island, some the historical homes of world-renowned figures such as gangster Al Capone. Home styles vary from Meditteranean and European-inspired mansions to artful contemporary coastal estates and villas.
Taking full advantage of the striking Biscayne Bay views, sunsets over the ocean, and sights of the downtown Miami skylines, many homes feature expansive outdoor pools, entertaining areas, and even rooftop lounge spots. The island is secluded yet close to all the happenings in the vibrant South Beach neighborhoods of Lincoln Road and the Art Deco District. Palm Island packages old Florida charm and glamour with modern sophistication and luxury.
5. Sunset Islands
Located in the pristine waters of Biscayne Bay is a group of four man-made islands known as the Sunset Islands. These islands represent highly coveted real estate within the Miami Beach area due to the level of seclusion, prestige, and beauty the homes on these islands provide. These islands are interconnected via a series of bridges. Sunset Islands I and II are connected to the idyllic beaches of Miami Beach, and Sunset Islands III and IV are just minutes away from the hip Sunset Harbor area.
All of the islands are guarded with gated entries that are manned 24/7 with security teams. The islands are perfect for watersports enthusiasts with direct access into the bay for paddleboarding, jet skiing, boating, and yachting. Many of the magnificent waterfront mansions and villas lining the islands' shores feature docks with deep enough waters for private boat or yacht storage.
Residences throughout the islands reflect the affluence and sophistication of the Sunset Islands’ homeowners with opulent Meditteranean, Art Deco, European-style and contemporary architecture. Oversized front and back yards provide ample privacy and perfect spaces for seamless indoor and outdoor entertaining. Sparkling pools, tropical landscaping, and tasteful balconies and patios are just a few of the many amenities found in the homes on the Sunset Islands.
6. Fisher Island
Fisher Island is the pinnacle of seclusion and luxury island living in South Florida and possibly the world. Boasting the highest per capita income of residents in all of the United States, Fisher Island is the ultimate destination for the globe’s wealthy and elite. The 216-acre island is only accessible via helicopter, private boat, or the 24-hour car and passenger ferry that runs between the mainland and Fisher Island.
The island has been the home to a long list of millionaires and billionaires, including famous athletes, entertainers, and business moguls. The former mansion belonging to the Vanderbilt family is now the sprawling Spanish-style Fisher Island Club. The high-end club features everything from tennis courts, a golf course, marina, spa, private white-sand beach, restaurant, and opulent hotel accommodations. Golf carts and bikes are the primary modes of transportation throughout the island’s quiet, meticulously maintained roads.
Homes on the island are a mix of exquisite waterfront mansions and luxury condominiums and townhomes. Many of the regal condominium properties enjoy waterfront access and views of Biscayne Bay. Whether desiring an extremely private waterfront estate or a posh, expansive condominium with breathtaking appointments and views, Fisher Island is the ultimate, luxurious hideaway for the rich and famous.
7. La Gorce
La Gorce Island is a small yet prestigious island adjacent to the La Gorce neighborhood in the North Beach locale of Miami Beach. With just under a hundred lavish properties on the island, it offers a tranquil yet refined ambiance for residents. The island is conveniently located minutes away from luxury shopping outlets such as Bal Harbor Shops and fine dining establishments along Collins Avenue.
The highly exclusive, members-only La Gorce Country Club is also just a short drive away along the bridge connecting the island to the La Gorce neighborhood. Entry to the island is strictly guarded 24/7, and the surrounding waters of the island are patrolled by marine security boats. Many island residents are members of the La Gorce Island Residents Association, which works to ensure the continued privacy and beauty of the island.
Throughout the island are enviable luxury mansions and villas, many on oversized waterfront lots. Home architecture on the island befits the affluent, tropical nature of the island featuring Meditteranean, Spanish, and sleek contemporary style elevations. Homeowners enjoy views of shimmering Biscayne Bay, with some homes having direct access to the water via private docks.
8. Venetian Islands
The Venetian Islands are a group of six artificial islands spanning from east to west in Biscayne Bay between the sparkling shores of Miami and Miami Beach. The six islands include Biscayne Island, San Marco, San Marino, Di Lido, Rivo Alto, and Belle Isle. While each island is unique in its size and community, all of the Venetian Islands provide outstanding views of the bay and a piece of South Florida paradise and luxury.
The islands are interconnected via the Venetian Causeway, which includes a series of drawbridges to allow for sea vessel passage. The Venetian Causeway is also a perfect spot for a jog, dog walk, or bike ride while taking in the breathtaking bay views and glimpses of the regal estates on the islands. The islands are almost strictly residential with the exception of Belle Isle being home to the popular art deco-inspired hotel and spa, The Standard.
Some of the islands provide 24-hour security and gated access, giving residents the utmost privacy. Many of the islands feature posh, waterfront mid and high-rise condominium properties with exceptional on-site amenities such as tennis courts, pools, playgrounds, and private beaches.
Opulent waterfront and interior lot estates are also common on the Venetian Islands. These mansions can often be found on oversize lots with private docks, stately entrances, tropical landscaping, and impressive indoor and outdoor entertaining areas. All of the islands provide convenient access to the artistic, vibrant cultures of either downtown Miami or Miami Beach without sacrificing exclusivity and privacy.
9. Bay Point
The Bay Point community is a highly prestigious and affluent enclave located in Miami’s Upper East Side. This upscale gated neighborhood offers exceptional privacy and security to its residents, with gate officers and a security team patrolling the community around the clock. This community boasts one of the country’s most upscale and expensive streets in regards to real estate, the famous Sabal Palm Road. With only 250 homes in the neighborhood, a Bay Point address is highly sought after by wealthy individuals, including celebrities, athletes, and business executives.
The community includes a number of waterfront estates with views overlooking the glistening Biscayne Bay, Sabal Lake, or the Sabal Waterway. The neighborhood was established in 1937, and as such, many of the homes were built between the 1940s to 1960s and hold historic significance to the area. These magnificent homes have been remodeled and modernized and feature a variety of styles including ranch homes, modern contemporary, Meditteranean, and mid-century. For those seeking the convenient adjacency to downtown Miami, coupled with exclusive, secluded living, Bay Point is the perfect tropical oasis.
10. Brickell Key
Brickell Key is an upscale island just minutes away from the cosmopolitan Brickell District of downtown Miami. The triangular-shaped island spans 44 acres and is exclusively made up of a mix of luxury high-rise condominium properties, a commercial office building, and an opulent hotel, The Mandarin Oriental. This 5-star hotel features a tri-level spa, multiple fine dining restaurants, and a secluded white sand beach only for guests.
The island also boasts close proximity to offices, high-end shopping, and dining within the Brickell District. The island is highly exclusive with a gated entry and offers everything from waterfront walking trails to a gourmet grocery market, dry cleaners, and a salon.
The eleven condominium tower properties offer residents the ultimate in posh residences and lifestyle amenities. Many of the residences include tennis courts, state-of-the-art fitness areas, pools, valet parking, concierge services, and basketball courts. Residents can enjoy spectacular views of the Biscayne Bay and the Brickell District skyline from their high-rise tower balconies and windows. Top-of-the-line flooring, finishes, and expansive floor plans complete these luxury condominiums merging high-rise, modern living with touches of island paradise and elegance.
11. Normandy Shores
The island of Normandy Shores is a resort-style retreat with an active, affluent community centered around golf, tennis, and enjoying the South Florida weather. The island is situated near its sister island, Normandy Isles, and is close to all the best shopping and dining in the North Beach area of Miami Beach. Residents have full peace of mind, with a guarded gate exclusive to residents of Normandy Shores.
The historic Normandy Shores Golf Club serves as the hub of the community and is a gathering place for residents. The impressive club features a challenging 18-hole golf course with waterway views, a delicious full-service restaurant, and numerous social events throughout the year. Tennis is another popular pastime on the island, with two remarkable parks offering tennis facilities and other amenities, including walking trails and sports fields.
Normandy Shores offers exceptional resort-style living with a variety of real estate options for every life stage. Lovely condominium communities and single-family residences line the island. Homes with peaceful golf course views provide a country club ambiance, while waterfront homes offer breathtaking views of Biscayne Bay and the downtown skyline. Many homes on the island have been remodeled, but some still feature their original mid-century architecture. Meditteranean, art deco, mid-century, and modern home styles can all be seen throughout Normandy Shores.
12. Normandy Isles
Normandy Isles is a unique fusion of a metropolitan neighborhood mixed with refined tropical island living. The island’s developer was a Frenchman, and his European heritage can still be seen throughout the island, from street names and nostalgic street lights to the historic Vendome Fountain at the east entrance of the island. Some of the island’s original commercial buildings and sections have been deemed historic icons and still retain their original charm and beauty to this day.
The downtown area is a bustling center filled with hip coffee shops, locally-owned restaurants, and a weekly farmer’s market for residents. The island is centrally located with easy access to the vibrant happenings of Miami Beach and is connected to its sister island, Normandy Shores, via the Bay Drive and Biarritz Drive bridges.
The island has two distinct sections. In the north portion of the island, attractive multi-family residences, condominiums, and single-family homes can be found. Many of the single-family homes in this area feature mid-century architecture from their original construction in the early 1950s and 1960s. In the south is a collection of resort-like condominiums and upscale waterfront homes. Many of these homes have direct access to Biscayne Bay and are beautiful examples of Miami Modern, Mediterranean, and contemporary architecture.
13. Biscayne Point
Biscayne Point is an upscale community that stretches across three islands in the beautiful azure waters of Biscayne Bay. The community is a part of the North Beach area of vibrant Miami Beach with easy access to the mainland via two auto bridges and a pedestrian bridge. This resort-like community includes a gated entry which contributes to the neighborhood’s peaceful palm tree-lined streets with little traffic.
Due to the community’s prime location, many of the residences enjoy breathtaking waterfront views of either Biscayne Bay or the Atlantic Ocean. Easy access to the ocean and Biscayne Bay makes watersports, boating, and yachting popular hobbies amongst Biscayne Point residents. Two expansive parks bookend the neighborhood and feature amenities such as dog play areas, playgrounds, and basketball courts. The community is also nearby two renowned golf courses located at Indian Creek Country Club and Normandy Shores Golf Club.
Biscayne Point offers a diverse array of real estate options, including waterfront homes along with modest and affordable single-family residences and condominiums. All different styles of homes are represented throughout the community, including Meditteranean, mid-century, bungalow-style, and contemporary. Biscayne Point is a tropical, waterfront community that offers something for every walk of life.
14. Belle Meade Island
Beautiful Belle Meade Island is a distinctive L-shaped island that is a part of Miami’s upper east side community. The island is located in the azure waters of Biscayne Bay, nestled right at the entrance to the Intracoastal Waterway.
This exclusive island community features secured gated access onto the island from the Belle Meade mainland neighborhood. Upon entry, residents and guests are immediately transported to a tropical paradise with stately palm trees, lush landscape, and attractive homes around every turn. The island is a small, close-knit community with numerous waterfront and interior lot homes. Some homes retain their historic charm, being built as far back as the mid-1930s and 1940s, but many have been updated and feature Meditteranean, mid-century and modern architecture.
The island’s unique location allows for uninhibited access into the ocean directly from waterfront homes’ private docks. The island is just a few minutes' drive to the mainland into Miami’s historic Mimo District or the neighborhood’s weekly farmer’s markets. Residents enjoy the privacy, luxury, and stunning bay view sunsets combined with the convenient accessibility to the ocean and mainland Miami.